Updated SIR testing vital for mission-critical electronics using lead-free alloys, says Gen3
FARNBOROUGH, UK – October 3, 2006 – Gen3 Systems Limited, a company dedicated to “Engineering Reliability in Electronics” has announced the release of revised Surface Insulation Resistance (SIR) standards designed to improve reliability and integrity testing of products assembled with lead-free solder.
Gen3 AutoSIR
IEC (International Electrotechnical Commission) has published a new SIR test standard (IEC 61189-5) on August 31, 2006. Additionally the US-based IPC (Association Connecting Electronics Industries) will also shortly release new SIR testing standards: IPC-TM-650 2.6.3.7 and IPC 9201A SIR Test Handbook. In addition, the IPC recently published a standard, employing SIR techniques, to determine the influence of sub-surface reactions known as CAF (Cathodic (or Conductive) Anodic Filamentation).
The new standards, for both individual materials and production process characterisation, adopt different test parameters for humidity, temperature, test duration, voltage bias, measurement frequency and test coupon, to take into account the effects of new production processes when using lead-free assemblies.
Lead-free assemblies are rapidly becoming the norm following the EU’s Restriction of Hazardous Substances (RoHS) legislation that passed into law on July 1, 2006. Any manufacturer now wishing to import electronic assemblies into the EU must ensure the printed circuit boards (PCBs), components and solder contain no lead. Similar RoHS legislation is likely in many US states and China in the near future.
“What is not widely appreciated is that modern lead-free electronic circuit production is dominated by chemistry, and pretty aggressive chemicals at that,” says Gen3 Systems’ MD Graham Naisbitt. “Ionic residues arise from a multitude of manufacturing process ‘contaminants’ such as unreacted plating residues, improperly cured solder resists, soldering fluxes and inadequately cleaned assemblies (including those manufactured using no-clean processes). Other contaminants may be non-ionic in nature, left behind, for example, by surfactants increasingly used to aid no-clean flux do its job.”
These ionic contaminants (in the presence of electric potential and humidity) can cause failure due to electro-chemical reactions. Exhaustive research by the world-renowned National Physical Laboratory (NPL) in the UK, and Concoat Systems (the forerunner of Gen3 Systems), determined that measurements of changes in SIR would be a valuable, if not essential, metric in determining the susceptibility of electronic circuits to electro-chemical failure.
However, to date, SIR testing has only been used to characterise individual process chemistries such as solder flux. In addition, NPL’s research has now shown the test parameters used for these tests have yielded grossly misleading data.
Now the revised standards define SIR testing procedures that can be used to characterise a process using a test vehicle assembled with the actual process materials used for modern lead-free, no-clean technology. In the new procedure the assembly under test is driven to failure to establish at what point reliability is compromised by the reactions of ionic (and non-ionic) residues. This is important because of the differences in lead-free assembly compared with production using eutectic solder (60% tin(Sn) and 40% lead(Pb)).
The IPC is now recommending lead-free alloys such as SAC305 (Sn96.5% Ag3.0% Cu0.5%) for electronics assembly. These solders require much higher reflow and flowsoldering temperatures (219ºC compared to 183ºC for eutectic solder).
“The higher processing temperatures typical of lead-free assemblies change how contamination forms. For example, all fluxes leave residues, but at elevated temperatures, these residues are more likely to be absorbed into the substrate increasing the overall ionic contamination,” says Naisbitt.
Gen3 Systems manufactures the Auto-SIR insulation resistance testing system. The system has been developed in collaboration with the NPL. The Auto-SIR tests to all major international standards, including the revised versions specifically recommended for lead-free assemblies. The Auto-SIR employs Frequent Monitoring Trend Analysis (FMTA). This can be used to monitor long-term process condition trends.
Naisbitt is a member of the International Electrotechnical Commission’s (IEC) TC91 WG3, the working group that formulates test standards for the assembly industry. He is also Leader of Solderability Testing Standard IEC 60068-2-69, Co-leader of Solderability Testing Standard IEC 60068-2-54, and Member of IPC-J-STD 002 and IPC-J-STD 003.
About SIR testing (product page)
SIR testing was established as a method for evaluating electronic assembly materials and processes as one measure of reliability. The objective of SIR testing is drive test coupons to failure to determine at under what conditions failure-inducing electrochemical reactions occur so that these conditions can be avoided during routine assembly.
Electrochemical failure occurs in the presence of electrical potential, moisture (from a humid environment) and ionic residue. If any of these is not present, electrochemical reactions can’t occur. The ionic residue can come from unreacted plating residues, improperly cured solder resist or from flux. These residues can cause corrosion, metal migration or dendritic growth leading to early failure.
SIR testing is performed with industry standard test coupons etched with patterns designed for the purpose (typically interdigitated combs). The insulation resistance of a test pattern is monitored at intervals as temperature and humidity are varied. Revised tests recommend test coupons complete with components.
There are several standards from organisations such as International Electrochemical Commission (IEC), IPC, International Standards Organisation (ISO) that largely replace the now defunct Bellcore specification. Each defines different humidity, temperature, test duration, voltage bias, measurement frequency and test coupon. It is recommended that technicians refer to the latest version of the IPC-9201 The SIR Handbook for detailed guidance on the subject.
About Gen3 Systems
Gen3 Systems is dedicated to tackling the demanding electronics reliability challenges of lead-free assembly and further electronics miniaturisation. The company is a specialist manufacturer of test and measurement equipment used to predict the reliability of electronic circuits and systems in the field. In addition, the company designs and manufactures conformal coating process equipment in both in-line and bench-top formats.
Gen3 Systems’ Managing Director Graham Naisbitt is a member of the IEC’s TC91 WG3, the working group that formulates test standards for the assembly industry. He is also leader of Solderability Testing Standard IEC 60068-2-69, Co-leader of Solderability Testing Standard IEC 60068-2-54, Co-Chair of IPC-TM-650 Test Methods Sub-Committee, and Member of IPC-J-STD 002 and IPC-J-STD 003, among many others.
Gen3 Systems is founded on the former Concoat Systems Limited. Concoat Systems and its company slogan “Engineering Reliability in Electronics” (which has been retained by Gen3 Systems) was a familiar name in Europe, Asia and much of North America. The new company was launched by its family owners after former sister company Concoat Limited was sold to US firm Chase Corporation in 2005.
Process Product Support is the new UK / Ireland market Division for Gen3 Systems, also bringing together many new distributed products from Marantz (AOI), ACE (Selective Soldering), Kirsten (Jet Wave Soldering), SAWA (specialist USC Systems) as well as R&D Technical Services (Vapour-Phase Systems), MB Tech (Cleaning Systems) and several others.
Gen3 Systems operates from new premises near Farnborough Business Park, on the M3 corridor and just 30 minutes from London’s Heathrow Airport. The company has an entirely new management team focused on the needs and requirements of its customers around the world.
Gen3 Systems also provides training, equipment and expertise for manufacturers requiring assessment of their electronic products’ reliability. The company also assists with standards development via both the IPC and IEC.
The company’s product range and services include:
- AUTOSIR Surface Insulation Resistance (SIR) test system
- MUST 3 solderability test system
- SOLDAPRO thermal profilers
- CM SERIES cleanliness test systems
- SC SERIES spray conformal coating systems, both batch and in-line
- DC SERIES dip conformal coating systems, both batch and in-line
- TEST SERVICES for circuit reliability, solderability and cleanliness
3rd Oct 2006